RICHMOND, Va. 鈥 Covering the Virginia governor鈥檚 race as a British graduate student felt like stepping into a living experiment in democracy. In the U.K., elections are brisk. Four to seven weeks of leaflets, a few polite hustings and everyone goes back to complaining about the weather. In America, politics is theater. The rallies have theme music, the crowds wear slogans and the flags are big enough to upholster the Palace of Westminster.
Our Battleground Virginia class at American University spent four days on the campaign trail 鈥 a mid-semester field experience to complement our in-class lectures 鈥 and what I found wasn鈥檛 just spectacle. It was a system in which forgiveness depends on your last name, as one candidate鈥檚 comeback would later show; where churches double as campaign headquarters; and where voters have stopped trying to persuade each other and started wearing their politics like their identity.

The divide was stark. Every event felt like a world apart. Red or blue, never both. At least in the U.K., people tend to put their national identity above their political one. In America, political identity often comes first.
The Sermon and the campaign.
Saturday began with former President Barack Obama鈥檚 return to Norfolk to endorse the then-candidate for governor, Democrat Abigail Spanberger. It was less a political event than a cultural pilgrimage. The crowd sang, danced and cried; 鈥渉ope鈥 wasn鈥檛 just a word but a rhythm. Having studied political oratory, I watched Obama like a craftsman watching a master, the balance of humor and seriousness, the control in his pacing, the pauses between applause lines. His tone was hypnotic, equal parts sermon and stand-up. He didn鈥檛 just deliver a speech. He conducted a symphony of belief.
The next morning, we were in Richmond, seated among the congregation at Third Street Bethel A.M.E. Church, a historic African American church with a long tradition of civic action. The Rev. Reuben Boyd鈥檚 sermon wove scripture and politics seamlessly. 鈥淭here are no kings here,鈥 he declared, to a chorus of amens. Church leaders spoke about plans for a March on Washington next year, faith mobilized into activism before our eyes.
Afterward, Gwen Faush-Carney 49, a member of the Delta Sigma Theta sorority, told me; 鈥淭hrough life鈥檚 experiences, God helps guide me. I鈥檓 independent when it comes to voting, but I share our church鈥檚 values of faith and service.鈥 When I asked what that meant in practice, she smiled. 鈥淚t means I vote Democrat, but I think about it first.鈥
In Britain, we keep faith and politics in separate pews. In America, they harmonize. The church isn鈥檛 just where you worship. It鈥檚 where you organize.
Liberty and the costume.

By Sunday afternoon, we were in Hanover County, where the Republican candidates for governor, attorney general and lieutenant governor rallied supporters alongside outgoing Gov. Glenn Youngkin. It felt less like a campaign event and more like a homecoming. 鈥淒on鈥檛 Tread on Me鈥 flags flapped above the crowd. One sign read. 鈥淒emocrats: your use of hatred has produced evil. Who will vote for you?鈥 The rally felt aimed at the faithful, not the undecided.
Among the crowd was a man dressed as Patrick Henry, 71, complete with a tricorn hat, who cheerfully introduced himself as the original Virginian patriot.
鈥淗e鈥檚 here every time,鈥 laughed Charlie Waddell, 68, a substitute teacher and former local official. 鈥淭he costume doesn鈥檛 change, and neither do the speeches.鈥 Then, with a shrug, he said, 鈥淭hey love Trump. That鈥檚 the glue.鈥
Roger Martin, a retired engineer attending his first rally, summed up the mood perfectly. 鈥淪pam is bad for your computer. 鈥楽pamberger鈥 is bad for Virginia.鈥 He laughed, then said of the Republican candidate, Winsome Earle-Sears, 鈥淪he stands for Trump, that鈥檚 enough for me.鈥
For a Brit, it was fascinating. American conservatism doesn鈥檛 do understatement; it comes draped in banners and conviction. Where British Tories mutter about heritage, Virginia Republicans shout about liberty.
The name brand.
On Monday, we met Don Scott, a Democrat and speaker of the House of Delegates, who mixed gravitas with good humor. The conversation turned to Jay Jones, the Democratic attorney-general candidate who had sent threatening texts to a Republican rival years earlier but remained on the ballot.

Scott defended Jones as a 鈥済ood man who made a mistake鈥 and questioned why the issue of his violent messages, recently published by The National Review, had lingered so long. Then came the telling line: 鈥淛ay鈥檚 dad was part of the Democratic establishment. He鈥檚 got a name brand. People know the Jones family.鈥
That night, Jones won comfortably. For an outsider, it was jarring. In Britain, a scandal like that would end a career. In America, or at least in Virginia, it鈥檚 a speed bump if your family has enough political capital. Tribal loyalty isn鈥檛 a bug. It鈥檚 the operating system.
Democracy as expression.
Election Day arrived, and students were dispatched to polling sites across Richmond and Norfolk to capture the mood of the electorate and file their notes and vignettes to 最新蜜桃影像ington Post. Outside Clover Hill High School, a leafy suburb of Richmond, Jenny Mylott, a 55-year-old accountant, called the vote 鈥渁 referendum on Trump.鈥
鈥淲e get government contracts, and now our company isn鈥檛 getting paid,鈥 she said. 鈥淚鈥檓 hoping this election makes Washington wake up and compromise. It just cannot be a single person controlling everything.鈥
Across town, Tony Clark, a 20-year-old student, offered a different angle.
鈥淭he campaign felt like it was run back in 2008. But this vote was a symbolic middle finger to D.C.鈥
Both saw their ballots not as civic duties but as acts of expression, one weary, one defiant, both deeply personal.
Victory and exhaustion.
When results night arrived, I joined the crowd at Spanberger鈥檚 victory rally in Richmond at the convention center, which buzzed with exhaustion and elation. When Spanberger finally took the stage, she thanked voters and her family and even teased her youngest daughter for not cleaning her room, a small, human moment that cut through the political theater.
To some, she was a centrist pragmatist; to others, she was simply 鈥渘ot Trump.鈥 In that room, those differences dissolved. Democracy felt tangible again, messy, noisy, occasionally absurd, but unmistakably alive.

What Britain doesn鈥檛 understand.
For a Brit abroad, the lesson was clear. In America, politics isn鈥檛 a conversation; it鈥檚 a calling. Faith groups mobilize, students organize, retirees proselytize. It鈥檚 less about left and right than about belonging, a contest not of policies but of identities.
The British system, for all its dullness, at least maintains the pretense of propriety. In America, standards are negotiable if you鈥檙e on the right team. But for all its flaws and theatrics, American democracy is gloriously alive. People shout because they care. They argue because they believe the system is still worth arguing over.
Loud, restless and endlessly unfinished, America鈥檚 democracy may not be tidy, but it is alive in a way Britain鈥檚 rarely feels.





Add comment